If your insurer sent a nonrenewal or cancellation notice while you’re still fixing storm damage, take a breath. What you’re feeling is normal:
- “They can’t drop me in the middle of a rebuild.”
- “Will my lender freak out?”
- “Does this kill my claim?”
Here’s the plain-English truth: your claim and your renewal status are separate issues. Carriers still have claim-handling obligations under applicable law and policy terms. From here on, stop venting by phone—put everything in writing.
We help policyholders understand their options and pursue the benefits available under their policies. Outcomes vary; expect responsibility for deductibles and any non-covered costs.
---
The First 72 Hours After a Nonrenewal During an Open Storm Claim (Checklist)
1) Confirm what it is: cancellation vs. nonrenewal
- Cancellation: mid‑term termination. Faster clock. Different rules.
- Nonrenewal: ends your policy at the expiration date.
- Action: Photo the envelope/letter (front/back), save email PDFs with metadata, and calendar the effective date.
2) Keep your claim alive (in writing)
- Send this reply: “We acknowledge receipt of your nonrenewal. This does not alter your duty to fully and fairly adjust my active storm damage claim. Please confirm all open tasks and deadlines.”
- Ask for a written claim status: inspections left, any due dates (Proof of Loss), ALE status, and who’s assigned.
3) Notify your mortgage servicer immediately
Send them the notice. Ask for their replacement coverage timeline before force‑placed insurance kicks in.
4) Mitigate and document
Tarp, dry‑out, board‑up. Keep invoices, permits, and time‑stamped photos/video.
5) Open a simple claim hub
- Two folders: “Claim” and “Nonrenewal/Underwriting.”
- Keep a communication log: date, who, and what was said/sent.
---
Can my home insurer nonrenew me while my claim is open?
Short answer: Often yes at term-end, but nonrenewal does not cancel your rights. They still owe full, fair claim handling under each state’s claims-handling and bad faith laws. They cannot use nonrenewal to coerce you into taking a lowball settlement.
After major disasters, regulators sometimes issue bulletins (moratoriums, notice extensions). Check your state’s site for current guidance:
- Louisiana Department of Insurance
- Texas Department of Insurance
- Mississippi Insurance Department
- Georgia Office of Commissioner of Insurance and Safety Fire
- Massachusetts Division of Insurance
---
Is the nonrenewal legal? How to spot red flags and challenge it fast
Notice requirements to verify
- Was it timely (often 30–60 days before expiration), in writing, and specific about the reason?
- Did they deliver it properly (mail/email rules matter in many states)? Defective notice can be invalid.
Reasons that often fail vs. pass (varies by state)
- Often restricted: weather-only catastrophe claims, losses you couldn’t reasonably prevent, a single storm claim.
- Commonly cited: roof age, repeated non-weather losses, inspection hazards. Make them prove it with documents.
Action steps you can take this week
- Demand the specific underwriting reason and the complete underwriting file: inspection photos/reports, third-party data (e.g., CLUE report).
- If their data is wrong, dispute in writing with contractor reports, repair photos, receipts, and permits.
- File a regulatory complaint if the reason is vague, retaliatory, or the notice is defective. All five states above have simple online forms.
- Template opener: “Please treat this as a formal appeal of your nonrenewal decision and provide all underwriting files supporting your decision within 10 business days.”
---
Keep your storm damage claim moving after nonrenewal
Build your evidence package
- Full photo/video set (exterior elevations, interior rooms, attic/sheathing); drone if safe.
- Independent estimate (Xactimate or comparable); moisture mapping; roof report (HAAG-certified if available).
- Contents spreadsheet: item, model/serial, link to replacement, and receipts.
Don’t miss the paperwork
- Sworn Proof of Loss (if demanded)—track that deadline and include exhibits.
- ALE diary (rent, meals, mileage). Ask for ALE extensions in writing when repairs require it.
- Copy your mortgagee on major claim updates; collect contractor W-9 and insurance.
Use procedural levers to accelerate
- Appraisal: If the dispute is “how much,” not “whether,” request it (preserve your litigation rights).
- Ask for claim file notes and all engineer/adjuster reports. Inconsistencies often force reevaluations.
- Set 10–14 day response deadlines in each email. If missed, escalate to a supervisor.
When to pivot to litigation
Unreasonable delays, lowballing without rationale, shifting reasons, or retaliation tied to nonrenewal are prime triggers to talk to Insurance Claim HQ’s trial team.
---
Replace your policy quickly—even with an open claim (coverage continuity playbook)
Start with an independent agent
- Ask who’s writing in your zip code now.
- Bring your prior declarations page, an open-claim summary, and mitigation proof (tarp/dry-out photos, invoices).
Inspections that help you get quoted in coastal/storm zones
- Four-point inspection and a wind mitigation report (common across Gulf and Atlantic markets).
- Letter from your contractor on temporary repairs and roof condition.
Fallback options by market
- Louisiana: Louisiana Citizens
- Texas: Texas FAIR Plan
- Mississippi: MWUA (wind pool)
- Georgia: Georgia Underwriting Association
- Massachusetts: FAIR Plan (MPIUA) These plans are pricier and tighter on coverage, but they preserve coverage continuity.
Force-placed insurance is a last resort
It’s expensive and often protects only the lender’s interest. Push to bind your own policy before your servicer’s deadline.
---
What if they cancel mid-term instead of nonrenew?
Immediate triage
- Identify the reason (non-payment, misrepresentation, inspection hazard). Some are curable within days.
- If non-payment: pay and request written reinstatement the same day.
If they allege misrepresentation or “discovered risk”
- Demand the application they claim is inaccurate and the underwriting file.
- Mid-term cancellations tied to a claim can cross into bad faith territory. Get counsel involved quickly.
---
Signs your carrier crossed the line (bad faith checklist)
Watch for these tactics
- Coercion: “We’ll nonrenew unless you accept this low settlement,” or “No ALE extension because you hired a lawyer.”
- Delay: repeated “re-inspections,” lost documents, silence beyond statutory deadlines.
- Misrepresentation: citing exclusions not in your policy, ignoring matching or ordinance-and-law coverage.
Preserve the record
- Keep everything in writing; confirm call summaries by email; save voicemails.
- Ask them to hold evidence (litigation hold) if you anticipate suit.
Plain-English note on the law
Every state has guardrails. Examples: Louisiana (R.S. 22:1892 and 22:1973), Texas (Prompt Payment of Claims—Chapter 542), Mississippi (Unfair Claims Settlement Practices), Georgia (O.C.G.A. 33-6-34), Massachusetts (Ch. 93A and 176D). You don’t need to memorize these—that’s our job—but they exist to stop the games.
---
Dollars and cents while coverage shifts
- Aim for a “deductible-only” outcome on the claim. Don’t start big repairs until scope and coverage are locked.
- Use contractor milestones and require lien waivers with each draw.
- Consider short-term rebuild financing if needed. Avoid assigning your claim unless your attorney recommends it.
---
Local fast-track resources (grounded examples)
Along I-10 between Metairie (near the 17th Street Canal) and Gulfport (Courthouse Rd area), tarp and dry-out crews book fast. Document wait times—this supports ALE extensions.
Regulators you can actually reach:
- Louisiana Department of Insurance—quick online complaints.
- Texas Department of Insurance—consumer help line and walk-in options in Houston.
- Mississippi Insurance Department—consumer services can nudge carriers.
- Georgia Insurance & Safety Fire—online form; they’ll assign an investigator.
- Massachusetts Division of Insurance—help with unfair claim practices and 93A/176D issues.
Meet us where you are
- Metairie HQ: 3001 17th Street, Metairie, LA 70002
- Gulfport: 204 Courthouse Rd, Suite A, Gulfport, MS 39507
- Houston: 1 Riverway, Houston, TX 77056
- Atlanta (Midtown): 1201 W Peachtree St NW, Suite 600, Atlanta, GA 30308
- Boston (Downtown): 44 School St, 6th Floor, Boston, MA 02108
Bring your nonrenewal letter and claim file. We’ll review it with you in plain English. Contact us to schedule a no-obligation strategy session.
---
How Insurance Claim HQ helps—and what it costs
We try cases. We take depositions. We do the hard legal work to pursue available policy benefits. We’re in polos and caps unless we’re in court, but we fight hard every day.
- Contingency-fee representation may be available where permitted by law. Court costs and case expenses may be the client’s responsibility, per the written engagement agreement.
- What to bring: your policy and dec page, nonrenewal/cancellation letter, claim correspondence, estimates/photos, mortgage information.
- Strategy map: demand letters, appraisal/mediation, storm damage litigation when needed, and bad faith claims where provable.
---
FAQs we answer in plain English
Will a new carrier cover existing damage?
No. New policies cover future losses. Disclose the open claim truthfully.
Does nonrenewal hurt me when shopping?
It can. Show mitigation proofs and inspection reports to offset the risk.
Can the insurer stop my ALE because of nonrenewal?
No. ALE depends on your policy and claim facts, not renewal status.
How long can they delay payment?
States set timelines to acknowledge, investigate, and pay. We’ll apply your state’s rules to your file.
Should I file a second claim for new leaks?
Yes if it’s a new event. Keep dates and events distinct to avoid denial confusion.
---
Ready when you are: your path to resolution
1) Lock down your claim evidence and deadlines.
2) Challenge any illegal nonrenewal and secure replacement coverage.
3) Choose the right lever—appraisal, mediation, or litigation—to force fair payment.
4) Rebuild with confidence. Budget for your deductible and any non-covered costs—policy terms control.
Schedule a free, fast claim + nonrenewal review at Insurance Claim HQ. We’re local to Metairie, Gulfport, Houston, Atlanta, and Boston, and our practice includes property insurance claims and litigation.
Visit insuranceclaimhq.com to get started.
Small print: This article is general information, not legal advice. Deadlines and rules vary by state and policy. If you’re up against a clock, contact us right away.
Attorney Advertising. General information only; not legal advice. Reading this content does not create an attorney–client relationship. Results vary; no guarantee. Representation is limited to jurisdictions where our lawyers are licensed, and we associate with local counsel when required. Contingency-fee representation may be available; court costs and case expenses may be the client’s responsibility as outlined in a written engagement agreement. Coverage outcomes depend on specific policy language and facts—review your policy and deadlines with a qualified attorney licensed in your jurisdiction.
